Off the Beaten Path Restaurants in Lahaina, Maui

When I mentioned I was traveling to West Maui, including Lahaina, for a few days, restaurant recommendations were in abundance. And though Longhis’s, Cheeseburger in Paradise and Kimo’s were amongst the most popular, they seemed too touristy and less trendy then my debatably sophisticated taste.

I am NOT the diner who will forgo incredible food just to have an ocean view. Or pay double because all the servers dress in grass skirts.

The following three restaurants in the town of Lahaina were off the beaten path and are not to be missed. You’ll be sorry. Really.

The Best Lahaina Restaurants

Star Noodle

Star Noodle is an Asian inspired noodle house were they make their own…noodles. Go figure.

Though the market price was $20 for the Ahi Avo (their version of poke) the quality and portion size was impressive. It was tossed with lemon pressed olive oil, sambal, usukuchi and topped with fresh avocado.

The Hapa Ramen was not like the 39 cent ramen I used to eat in college.

These noodles ($12) were handmade, submerged in pork broth with roasted pork. The poached egg on top was begging to be broken and enter into the mix.

Star Noodle Restaurant in Lahaina

100 Wines

100 Wines is a restaurant concept I would steal if I had plans on opening another eatery; featuring a large selection of unique wines, a rustic warm environment and tapas that will blow your mind.

The Brussel Sprouts in a Jar ($10) was the best version of this vegetable I have ever…EVER…had, it was no wonder that it’s the most popular menu item.

Then again, you can pretty much add hunks of pancetta, parmesan and balsamic reduction to any dish and it would be my favorite.

The Waygu burger tasted just as gamey as you want for a specialty meat and was only enhanced by the slab of bacon on top. Somehow, they must have heard about my truffle fries addiction, because that’s exactly what it came with.

Leoda’s Kitchen & Pie

Leoda’s is in the same restaurant group as Star Noodle and they had me hooked simply with the counter deli case filled with pies; banana cream, apple, macadamia nut, etc. Which shall I choose?

The pork, pork, umm pork sandwich could cure anybody’s piggy addiction.

It was layered with salami, bacon and prosciutto and served on buttered and browned bread. You must butter your bread before you put it on the grill in order to get that glistening deliciousness.

The deep-fried Mac n cheese was an unexpected surprised. I’m not sure why, it was exactly what it said, deep fried balls of creamy Mac n cheese served with tomato dipping sauce. Put a little porky in that and I would have accumulated another addiction.

And then it was time for pie. Peter wanted apple, I wanted banana cream…we got both.

Get the pie people. They know how to make a flaky crust and execute a filling.

After you have overindulged in ahi, brussel sprouts and pie you are bound to be parched. Head over to Maui Brewing Company and get yourself a glass of Pineapple Wine and a sample of Chipotle infused lager.

Warning: the Chipotle Lager will taste like chewing tobacco, but if you are anything like me you won’t be able to pass up at least tasting this strange drink.

What’s your favorite restaurant in Maui? Have you ever had Chipotle lager?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through my links, I earn a commission that helps to keep this blog running—at no extra cost to you. For more information read my full disclosure.

You Might Also Enjoy

Maui Bucket List: 40 Best Things To Do on the Top Hawaiian Island
Maui Luau: 6 of the Best Hawaiian Luaus on the Island
Maui Revealed: The Ultimate Guidebook

Walk a Black Sand Beach on the Road to Hana
Facing Pineapple Gluttony in Hali’imaile
Swim with Sea Turtles in Olowalu
35 of Maui’s Best Road to Hana Stops for a Fun Driving Tour

6 thoughts on “Off the Beaten Path Restaurants in Lahaina, Maui”

  1. You made me excited about food in maui and I don't even have any upcoming plans to go there! But when I do, I'll come back to this post. I want to try it all.

  2. Have been on Maui for the past 2 weeks and have eaten at Star Noodle and Leoda’s. We couldn’t agree more with your reviews!! Hope to get to 100 Wines before we leave.

  3. Funny that Leoda’s is ‘off the beaten path’ .
    You can’t even Get to Lahaina without driving right by Leoda’s. Great place.


Leave a Comment

Hey Bucket Listers!
I'm Annette.

I’m a goal obsessed mid-lifer, traveler, experience collector, fear crusher, digital marketer and author with big bucket list dreams. Let's Connect!

Want Inspo To Your Inbox?

I’m giving you practical tips, exclusive tools and the inspiration to stop dreaming about your bucket list and start living it.