Buying whole grain cognac mustard is expensive, a dinky jar can cost you 5 bucks and last about 5 minutes. Especially if you are like me and enjoy dipping your pretzels in a delicious mustard.
So, my husband had the innovative idea of making our own cognac mustard, something I would have never thought of. Surprisingly, I had never seen a cooking show on how to make mustard, which made me wonder if it was so complicated that it could never be explained in one short 30 minute television episode. Nope, it’s actually so easy that I am now annoyed with the grocery store for overcharging.

COGNAC MUSTARD RECIPE
6 Tbls Yellow Mustard Seeds
2 Tbls Brown Mustard Seeds
1/3 Cup Water
3 Tbls Cognac
2/3 Cup White Wine Vinegar
1/4 Cup Light Brown Sugar
1 tsp Salt
Mix mustard seeds, water, liquor, and vinegar in a bowl. Cover and let sit at room temperature for 3 days. Add brown sugar and salt. Process until semi smooth.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through my links, I earn a commission that helps to keep this blog running—at no extra cost to you. For more information read my full disclosure.
More Delicious Recipes
Best-Ever Homemade Beef & Mushroom Chili Recipe
Recipe: Italian Sausage & Oven Roasted Eggplant Farro Risotto
Foodie Bucket List: 30 Things Every Food Lover Must Do
Weird Food Bucket List: 60 Strange Foods From Around the World
I love me a good mustard. I'll have to try this out. Is it a little spicy?
It is just a little spicy. I think you could add peppercorns to the recipe if you’d like to spice it up more. It’s super easy to make!
This looks delicious! Does it taste like regular brown mustard? Could I eat it with a hot dog? :)
It tastes like a yummy spicy dijon. A hot dog would welcome its deliciousness ;)
This looks great. I have a love of Chinese hot mustard that is super expensive. I might have to try this out!